Home 9 Media law reform and legislation 9 Zimbabwe’s ConCourt confirms criminal defamation unconstitutional

Zimbabwe’s ConCourt confirms criminal defamation unconstitutional

MISA Zimbabwe team after filling for the courts to strike down criminal defamation
16 Feb, 2016
The Constitutional Court on 3 February 2016 granted an application by MISA- Zimbabwe seeking confirmation of the fact that criminal defamation is no longer part of the law. The ruling followed a concession by the State that Section 96, which provides for criminal defamation under the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act (CODE), was void […]

The Constitutional Court on 3 February 2016 granted an application by MISA- Zimbabwe seeking confirmation of the fact that criminal defamation is no longer part of the law.

The ruling followed a concession by the State that Section 96, which provides for criminal defamation under the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act (CODE), was void ab initio (from the beginning), which effectively brings the matter to finality.

Arguing the case on behalf of the applicants comprising MISA-Zimbabwe,  journalists Nqaba Matshazi, Sidney Saize, Godwin Mangudya and Roger Stringer, Advocate  Thembinkosi  Magwaliba, argued that Section 96 was invalid from the time of its enactment in 2004.

In his ruling, Chief Justice Chidyausiku sitting with the full bench of the Constitutional Court, granted the application in terms of the draft order sought, but said reasons for the judgment would follow.

This application follows judgment in the case of Madanhire and Others in 2013 in which the court ruled that Section 96 of the CODE was inconsistent with the provisions of Section 20 of the former constitution which provided for freedom of expression, and was therefore void.

MISA Zimbabwe Position

MISA Zimbabwe welcomes the ConCourt  judgment that vindicates its incessant calls for the scraping of this law from the statute books.

It has always been the position of MISA Zimbabwe that such laws have no place in a democratic society given that there are alternative civil remedies available to aggrieved parties outside criminal defamation.

Such remedies include filing complaints with bodies such as the Voluntary Media Council of Zimbabwe and civil actions for defamation in courts of law.

While this judgment is a welcome development, MISA Zimbabwe remains mindful of the fact that there is a litany of statutes that can still be used to criminalise freedom of expression and journalistic enterprise such as the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act, Official Secrets Act and the Censorship and Entertainment Controls Act, and the Broadcasting Services Act, among others.

About MISA

The Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA) was founded in 1996. Its work focuses on promoting, and advocating for, the unhindered enjoyment of freedom of expression, access to information and a free, independent, diverse and pluralistic media.

Share this

Related news

25 years on: Reflections on media law reforms

25 years on: Reflections on media law reforms

We are pleased to announce that in commemoration of our 25 years of existence as an institution, MISA Zimbabwe has made available a special publication titled; MISA Zimbabwe @25: Reflections on media law reforms. Below is a statement from our Board of Trustees...

Recommittal of Cyber Security Bill in the Senate: Letter to Parly

Recommittal of Cyber Security Bill in the Senate: Letter to Parly

MISA Zimbabwe has written to the Speaker of Parliament to highlight its concerns arising from the recommittal of the Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill to the Senate. Below is a copy of the letter sent to Parliament this morning; 4 August 2021 Honourable Advocate...

Zimbabwe Parliament applauded for robust debate on ZMC Bill

Zimbabwe Parliament applauded for robust debate on ZMC Bill

MISA Zimbabwe is encouraged by the robust and non-partisan debate in Parliament on 24 September 2020 on the Zimbabwe Media Commission Bill. This is a positive and progressive step towards promoting democratic governance in Zimbabwe. It is the constitutional role of...